Fenwick Island Restaurants

Casual, fine dining and carry-out in Fenwick Island.

Listed alphabetically, these Fenwick Island Restaurants are places with all levels of food and/or snacks along Coastal Highway (Rt 1) and Lighthouse Road (Rt 54) west to the Fenwick Ditch. West Fenwick eateries are continued on the page, Dining on Route 54.

crab claw vertical
One crab claw reaching for the sky…
  • Bahama’s Crabshack Carryout Seafood
  • Crepes and Crazes
  • Dirty Harry’s Restaurant & Bakery
  • Fenwick Crab House
  • Fisher’s Popcorn
  • Grab & Go Taco
  • Harpoon Hanna’s Restaurant
  • High Stakes Bar & Grill
  • Jimmy’s Kitchen
  • Just Hooked
  • Our Harvest
  • Kohr Bros Frozen Custard
  • Mancini’s Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant
  • Matteo’s Salsa Loco
  • One Coastal
  • Royal Farms
  • Surf’s Edge Deli
  • Twilley’s Willys, Village of Fenwick
  • Warren’s Station

In addition to Fenwick Island Restaurants, also visit Ocean City online.

Warren’s Station & Mile High Ice Cream Pie

Right smack dab in the middle of Fenwick Island

…bay side of Coastal Highway about a mile north of the MD/DE state line – stands Warren’s Station Family Restaurant – home of the world famous (well, locally famous, anyway) Mile High Ice Cream Pie.

If you’ve got a hankering for a chocolate sundae for dessert it may just be worth your while to get to Warrens Station for dinner. Just don’t eat too much – because you’ll need some serious room for a slice of this Mile High (well, really about nine inches) Ice Cream Pie. Pie? Really? Yes-sir-eee, it is a pie – complete with a bottom crust, a filling of both vanilla and chocolate ice cream and covered with a sweet meringue (and baked, at that). All of that is drizzled with an ample supply of rich chocolate sauce. It absolutely has all the makings of a chocolate sundae – but served on a flat plate instead of in a deep dish. And, yes, is is delicious – and there is even plenty to share. In fact, sharing is recommended if you’ve already had something to eat.

Warrens Station Family Restaurant is located at 1406 Ocean Hwy, Fenwick Island, DE 19944. Call 302-539-7156. Note, please, that Warren’s Station is closed from the end of September or early October until Mother’s Day.